Vigo County Historical Society

Even now, people can come and be a part of the Stiffy Green legend

The story of Stiffy Green, part fact and part fiction, has been one of Vigo County’s most popular legends. It has been told many times, especially in the fall of the year, but, like Stiffy, never grows old.

The tale goes that Stiffy was a pet of the John Heinl family. After his master’s death in 1920, the dog sat outside the family mausoleum at Highland Lawn Cemetery until he died of grief.

Because of his devotion to his master, the surviving relatives had him stuffed and placed inside the tomb. There he sat, guarding his owner, and glaring out with cold, green eyes.

The legend persists that Stuffy and his master sometimes took strolls together and that barking and whining could be heard throughout the cemetery on cool fall evenings.

As the years passed, "going to see Stiffy" became an adventure for Terre Haute youths on a date. What better way to frighten a girl into your arms than to go to Highland Lawn

Cemetery, shine a flashlight into the tomb and see Stiffy’s glass eyes glowing.

Unfortunately, about 12 years ago vandalism occurred at the mausoleum. A bullet passed through the glass door and shattered Stiffy’s glass eye.

It was then that the great-grandchildren of John Heinl made the decision to have the dog removed from the tomb and given to the Vigo County Historical Society. The Terre Haute Lioness Club took on the project of having a replica of the mausoleum constructed to created the proper atmosphere to perpetuate the legend. The exhibit that resulted has been a favorite of visitors.

On Saturday, a children’s program will be given in the Historical Museum. From 2 to 4 p.m., youngsters will have a chance to explore the legend, make a mask and doggie biscuit, and have a photo taken with Stiffy as a souvenir. A fun afternoon is planned. Reservations may be made by calling (812) 235-9717.